| 2023 - Nettie Olsen | 2022 - Donna Meyer | 2021 - Arlene Gaitan |
| 2020 - Nicole Miller | 2019 - Sherry Guess | 2018 - Carolyn VandenBerg |
| 2017 - Barbara Harty | 2016 - Leslie Rohrer | 2015 - Inez Campbell and Ed LaVallee |
| 2014 - Bess Bruton | 2013 - Kathleen Jones | 2012 - Vera Muckleroy |
| 2011 - Meg Flemming | 2010 - Evie Tumlin | 2009 - Lyndon Rife |
| 2008 - Sally Chionisini | 2007 - Kat Kyle | 2005 - Sarah Jane Martin |
| 2004 - Michele Voorhees | 2003 - Burnis Foy | 2002 - Bee Pape |
| 2001 - Kathleen George | 2000 - Molly Wallin | 1999 - Leigh Olejer |
| 1998 - Lauralyn Bushager | 1997 - Paul Kathen | 1996 - Sherry Arndt |
| 1995 - Charlotte Kerr | 1994 - Fran Dearing and Lurena Bell | 1993 - Becky Snell |
